How to BBQ for a Crowd on Thanksgiving

Thanksgiving is a time for family, friends, and feasting. Traditionally, it’s all about the roasted turkey, mashed potatoes, and cranberry sauce, but for those of us who are passionate about BBQ, there’s nothing quite like adding a smoky, grilled twist to the holiday.

If you’re planning to host a Thanksgiving BBQ for a crowd, it’s essential to get the details right—from how much food to prepare, to managing your cooking time effectively, and ensuring everything looks as good as it tastes.

Let’s dive into the essentials of how to BBQ for a crowd on Thanksgiving, making sure your holiday gathering is as stress-free and delicious as possible.

Estimating Food Quantities for Large Gatherings

When you’re planning a BBQ for a large group, one of the most nerve-wracking aspects is figuring out how much food to prepare. You want to make sure there’s plenty to go around, but you also don’t want to be stuck with an overwhelming amount of leftovers. The key is to strike a balance by carefully estimating the food quantities.

Meat and Side Dish Ratios

The heart of any BBQ is the meat, but the side dishes are just as crucial for rounding out the meal. Here’s how to get your quantities right:

• Main Protein: As a general rule of thumb, you should plan for about 1/2 pound of meat per adult. This guideline works well for traditional BBQ meats like brisket, ribs, or pulled pork. If you’re serving multiple meats, such as turkey and smoked ham, adjust the total amount accordingly. For instance, plan on serving 1/4 pound of turkey and 1/4 pound of ham per person. For children, 1/4 pound of meat per child should suffice.
• Side Dishes: Sides provide the necessary balance to the rich, smoky flavors of BBQ. For each side dish, plan on 1/4 pound per person. If you’re offering a variety of sides—say, five or six options—this will add up to about 1 1/4 pounds of sides per person. This allows your guests to sample a little bit of everything without overwhelming their plates.
• Bread and Rolls: Don’t overlook the bread, especially if you’re serving BBQ staples like pulled pork or brisket that pair perfectly with a soft roll. Plan for one roll or slice of bread per person, plus a few extras in case anyone goes back for seconds.

Vegetarian and Vegan Options

Even at a BBQ, it’s important to cater to guests with dietary preferences or restrictions. Offering vegetarian and vegan options doesn’t have to be complicated, and with a little creativity, these dishes can be just as exciting as your main meat offerings.

• Grilled Vegetables: Vegetables like portobello mushrooms, bell peppers, and zucchini are hearty and can take on the smoky flavors of the grill.
• Vegan Burgers or Sausages: With the variety of plant-based meat alternatives available today, you can easily include vegan burgers or sausages on your menu.
• Hearty Salads and Grains: Incorporate a grain-based salad, like quinoa or farro, mixed with roasted vegetables, nuts, and a tangy dressing. This type of dish is filling and can stand on its own as a main course for your vegetarian guests.
• BBQ Tofu or Tempeh: For a true BBQ experience, consider grilling tofu or tempeh. These plant-based proteins absorb marinades wonderfully and can be grilled to achieve a smoky, caramelized exterior that even meat-lovers will enjoy.

Time Management for BBQ Cooking

Managing your time efficiently is crucial when you’re cooking for a large group, especially if you want everything to come out perfectly cooked and served on time. BBQ is all about patience and timing, so here’s how to manage the cooking process like a pro.

Prepping in Advance: What Can Be Done Early?

Prepping as much as you can in advance is the secret to a smooth BBQ experience. The more you can do ahead of time, the less stressful your day will be.

• Marinate and Season Meats: Marinating or brining your meats the night before not only infuses them with flavor but also allows you to check one major task off your list. Whether you’re doing a dry rub for your ribs or a wet brine for your turkey, give the meats at least 12-24 hours to absorb the flavors.
• Prep Vegetables and Sides: Chop, slice, and dice all your vegetables the day before, and store them in airtight containers in the fridge. This applies to everything from the veggies you’ll be grilling to the ingredients for your side dishes. If you’re making a salad, you can wash and dry the greens ahead of time as well.
• Make Cold Sides and Desserts: Dishes like potato salad, coleslaw, or desserts such as pies and cakes can be made a day or two in advance. Cold sides taste even better when the flavors have had time to meld, and desserts are always best when they’re made ahead of time so you can focus on the main meal.

Tips for Cooking Multiple Dishes Simultaneously

When you’re cooking for a large group, you’ll often need to juggle several dishes at once. Here’s how to keep everything under control:

• Stagger the Start Times: Start with the dishes that take the longest to cook, such as your turkey, brisket, or pork shoulder. Once those are on the grill or in the smoker, you can begin working on faster-cooking items like sausages, burgers, or veggies. This way, everything will be ready around the same time.
• Use Indirect Heat: Indirect heat is your best friend when you need to keep things warm without overcooking. If your grill has multiple burners, you can use one side for cooking and the other for keeping finished dishes warm. This technique is particularly useful for delicate items that could dry out if left on direct heat.
• Smoking for the Win: If you have a smoker, use it to cook your larger cuts of meat. The low and slow method of smoking is perfect for big gatherings because it frees up your grill for other dishes and ensures that your meat is tender and full of flavor.
• Managing Grill Space: If you’re working with limited grill space, cook in batches. For example, cook all your vegetables first, then wrap them in foil and keep them warm in an insulated cooler or warming drawer while you move on to the meat.

Serving and Presentation Tips

After all the effort you’ve put into cooking, it’s time to think about how you’ll serve and present your food. Presentation matters, especially when you’re hosting a holiday gathering. A little extra effort in how you set up your buffet or dining area can elevate the entire experience.

Buffet-Style BBQ Setup

A buffet-style setup is ideal for large gatherings, particularly when it comes to BBQ. It allows guests to help themselves, which not only speeds up the process but also ensures everyone gets exactly what they want.

• Arrange Food Strategically: Start with the main proteins, followed by the sides, and then bread and rolls. This order ensures that guests load up on the most important items first and don’t fill up on sides or bread before they get to the BBQ meats.
• Label Each Dish: Clearly label each dish, especially if you have a mix of traditional, vegetarian, and vegan options. This helps avoid confusion and makes sure everyone can easily identify what they’re eating.
• Use Large Serving Platters: Large serving platters and bowls minimize the need for constant refills and create a more elegant, cohesive look. This is particularly important if you’re hosting a larger crowd, as it keeps the buffet line moving smoothly.
• Add a Decorative Touch: Incorporate seasonal elements like small pumpkins, gourds, or autumn leaves into your buffet setup. Not only does this enhance the visual appeal, but it also ties the theme of Thanksgiving into your BBQ feast.

Keeping Food Warm Throughout the Event

Ensuring your food stays warm throughout the event is key to maintaining its deliciousness. Here are a few ways to keep everything at the right temperature, so your guests can enjoy their meal at its best.

• Chafing Dishes and Warming Trays: These are great for keeping sides like mashed potatoes, stuffing, or baked beans warm. If you don’t have chafing dishes, you can use large pans placed over sternos (small heating elements) to achieve the same effect.
• Insulated Coolers: Believe it or not, a high-quality cooler can keep your meats warm for several hours. After removing your smoked meats from the grill, wrap them in foil, then in a towel, and place them in a cooler. This method is especially useful for items like brisket or pork shoulder, which benefit from resting before being sliced.
• Grill Top Warming Racks: If your grill has a warming rack, use it to keep dishes warm while you’re finishing up other items. Just be sure to keep the heat low so you don’t end up overcooking anything.
• Serve in Batches: Instead of putting all your food out at once, consider serving it in batches. This way, you can keep some items warm on the grill or in the oven while guests are eating, ensuring that second helpings are just as warm and delicious as the first.

FAQs

Conclusion

Hosting a Thanksgiving BBQ for a crowd is no small feat, but with the right planning and execution, it can be one of the most memorable holiday gatherings you’ll ever host. By carefully estimating food quantities, prepping in advance, managing your cooking times, and paying attention to how you serve and present your meal, you’ll ensure that your BBQ is a hit from start to finish.

So, get your grill fired up, gather your loved ones, and enjoy a Thanksgiving filled with great food, laughter, and the unmistakable flavors of BBQ.

Disclosure: Our blog contains affiliate links to products. We may receive a commission for purchases made through these links. However, this does not impact our reviews and comparisons. We try our best to keep things fair and balanced, in order to help you make the best choice for you.